I beat Witcher 3. It would have won GOTY easily last year. It isn’t an innovative game, though. Combat is run-of-the-mill RPG. You work alone most of the time. Collecting things is a chore. The best parts of W3 are cutscenes (which are amazing). MGSV is far more dynamic, and you have a buddy system where you can choose a combat partner. Customization of everything from weapons, partners, loadouts, etc. I love both games, but MGSV deserves GOTY more than W3.