Apple Cinnamon Jam is a jam that tastes like a dessert! This is one of those small batch canning Seriously, Dear Reader, this Apple Cinnamon Jam is like having apple pie filling on your toast every. Apples cook down into jam easily, have a great flavor, and they're easy to prepare. Select your favorite apples and decide if you'd like to make a. Taste apple-pie-in-a-jar with this recipe for DIY no-pectin apple jam that features a blend of nutmeg, cinnamon, cloves, and allspice.