My main problem with "list" type questions (be they game recommendations or other) is that the question is asking for a list, and logically for any answer to be accepted it would need to provide such a list. All posted answers in such questions tend to be, in essence, only 1/10 or 1/20 of the "real" answer; allowing such seems to be sending exactly the wrong message for a Q&A site which seeks canonical answers to real questions. Whether it's on-topic or not is secondary to the fact that, as posted, the question is ill suited for this Q&A format. – goldPseudo Jun 14 '12 at 22:09