Yea, but was that Jeans Idea? What I wanna know is If Neil wishes for a puppy, Jean just responds with ‘No, you can’t have a puppy’, and not turn Roger into a dog. You know? I mean, was it Jeans free will to turn the sailor into the captain? Maybe she thinks she did it of her own free will, but could she have refused? And I’m not just saying subvert the wish, like turning him into Daryl Dragon of the Captain & Tennille, I’m saying actually not granting anything.