As for Kate, she was actually being kind of horrible to Toby, who showed up at her weight-loss camp to help her out. While there, the creepy stable guy, Duke, couldn’t help but jump at the chance to imply that he and Kate had hooked up, obviously stunning Toby. After Kate snapped at Toby again for “annoying” her, he revealed he had actually brought his grandmother’s ring with him to surprise Kate, but then he left like she wanted.