Recently I was approached to read the latest novel from M.J. Rose, recommended based on the fact that I enjoy Anne Rice. I really do like Rice’s work, and figured if I could find a similar author I would be happy. What I didn’t even take into consideration was that this might be more like A. N. Roquelaure (Rice’s pen name for her more erotic work). Irrespective of, I started the book thinking that I would venture out of my comfort zone to try out something different (I have been trying that lately), and within the first two chapters I established that I did not like Sandrine’s character – I found her flat, annoying and weak, not interesting and compelling, someone I felt for. Not only that, we keep getting told what a strong character she is, but that character never really comes to the fore. I also found Grand-mére to not be layered enough – I was getting really excited to learn more about courtesans of the time, but that was basically mentioned over and over, but never elaborated on. Also, suddenly Grand-mére was a harbinger of death and all, but never actually substantiated. I know that the novel is set in the 1890s, but it doesn’t consistently feel that way, and Rose’s writing style doesn’t necessarily always reflect it, either, so you never get completely drawn into and lost in the novel. That and the shallow characters you don’t really care about means that The Witch of Painted Sorrows never resonates and stays with you. The relationship between Julien and Sandrine was flat and bland, for me, and the sex mirrored that, too. I also never got to the place where I cared about Sandrine’s plight, or what she was going to do. Events trundled along, but never really went anywhere too quickly. I wish there had been a more solid nad convincing plot. I found it to be an easy read, but it only really picks up towards the end, drawing you in then, but leaving oh so many questions unanswered. It was more interesting, but also rushed, disjointed and flawed. There was plenty potential for the novel though, I just feel that none of it was used to the best advantage it could have been. I liked how fantasy was woven throughout the book, and enjoyed when you finally got some more history on La Lune and her past. That was a whole different thing. I wanted to know more of that. The supernatural was sort of glanced over in here, never given too much flesh, but plenty of allusion. Then again, this was out of my comfort zone, and didn’t really play up to what I was hoping for, but maybe those enjoying a supernatural romance as a genre might like this substantially more.