Hands down the Witcher 3. The story in mgsv sucks, every mission is either rescue, extract, or destroy, over and over. It is repetitious and monotonous, even with doing missions different ways. It recycles the locations over and over. The 2nd chapter is sloppily put together with missions and re-dos that are absolutely unnecessary padding. And for an open world, the player sure is restricted from engaging in a lot of it. Would have been much better if there was more freedom to climb all those places we can see in the game, rather than a designated crack here and there.